We have detected that you are using an adblocking plugin in your browser.

The revenue we earn by the advertisements is used to manage this website. Please whitelist our website in your adblocking plugin.

SCRUTINY | Competition Heats Up At Montreal International Music Competition Finals Day One

By Jennifer Liu on May 10, 2017

Giuseppe Guarrera (Photo: Brent Calis)
nnounce the Giuseppe Guarrera (Photo: Brent Calis)

MONTREAL — Last night, the final round of the Montreal International Music Competition (MIMC) kicked off with three pianists presenting vastly different concerti, accompanied by the Montreal Symphony Orchestra under the baton of Claus Peter Flor. The finals continue tonight, after which the judges’ rankings will be announced at Friday’s gala concert.

In concerto performances, soloists tend to draw more inspiration from their surroundings than in a solo recital, as a concerto calls for the added input of a conductor and over 92 orchestra musicians. Thus, a successful performance requires consistent teamwork as well as clear projection of the soloist’s musicality. Under these circumstances, the soloist could be either inspired to new sonic highs and lows by the orchestra’s soundscape, or petrified by the magnitude of the endeavor, or flatly unprepared for the final round due to time constraints. Of note that the top six pianists at the MIMC will be ranked regardless of their performance in previous rounds.

Albert Cano Smit began the evening with Brahms’s Concerto No. 1 in D Minor. Weaving his way through the previous rounds with a program of fugues and textured music, Cano Smit had thus established his reputation as a structural craftsman. In this final round, his sound palette was particularly underdeveloped, and it was not until well into the first movement that he began warming into the orchestra’s breadth. Ultimately, the concerto exposed his inability to sustain an expansive tonal range. This extended into a slight conflict of artistic vision between pianist and orchestra, and it was the latter that tended to keep the performance moving. Is this a reflection of Cano Smit’s youth, and does this determine his suitability for chamber music settings? Time will tell for this musical pianist, though the competition results will likely reveal that he will not be the strongest finisher.

In a sharp break from mainstream concerto repertoire, Zoltán Fejérvári performed a spirited and sensitive Bartók Concerto No. 3. This proud representative of Hungary certainly tailored his entire competition program to his ethno-musical heritage, and consistently brought fresh energy to each round. In the Bartók, Fejérvári rose above its rhythmic particularities, demonstrating yet again his flexibility for various musical styles: throughout the performance, he shifted like mercury through various moods — some called for in the music, others intuited, always with a laissez-faire attitude. The jury will decide if this counter-current concerto will be convincing enough to outshine the others, which are more firmly rooted in the standard classical music repertoire.

Giuseppe Guarrera delivered the thrill of the evening in a wholesome performance of the Tchaikovsky Concerto No. 1. In a sharp contrast to his previous rounds, the sunny Italian pianist assumed the temperament of a full-blooded Russian, and he augmented his existing musical sensitivity with a newfound authority of a concerto veteran-to-be. Pianist and orchestra worked well together with fluid interplay: at times delivering ideas in solidarity, at times waging a friendly competition for musical themes, their overall goal remained to collectively bring majesty to the concerto. A split second of potential collapse was quickly reintegrated seamlessly into the performance by Guarrera, without missing a beat. Otherwise zipping through technical flourishes and channeling moments of Italianate charm, Guarrera left the audience with much to admire: assuredness in his solo role, clarity of vision, a tasteful yet wholesome interpretation of the concerto, and a comfortable demeanor on stage. Many winners have been crowned thanks to this Tchaikovsky — has it secured Guarrera a spot on the MIMC podium?

For judges and audiences alike, it is no easy task to distinguish between pianists such as those at the MIMC. Pianists and keyboard instrumentalists have one vital asset: the ability to play harmonies simultaneously with melody and other layers, which adds to the depth of interpretation. Whether or not at the MIMC, a pianist should strive to have the harmonies inform their playing; subsequent musical elements will then be built upon this foundation. Where others who had not capitalized on this dimension did not advance in the Competition, the judges will be watching for those who have integrated the composer’s harmonies — along with many other considerations — among the remaining pianists.

Musical Toronto continues coverage of the final day of the MIMC tonight.

#LUDWIGVAN

Want more updates on Toronto-centric classical music news and reviews before anyone else finds out? Follow us on Facebook or Twitter for all the latest.

Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_high_590x300
comments powered by Disqus

FREE ARTS NEWS STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX, EVERY MONDAY BY 6 AM

company logo

Part of

Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
© 2024 | Executive Producer Moses Znaimer